Molasses baked beans with a touch of sass

Molasses baked beans

I associate February with crazy storms. When I was in grade three our region was hit with the Groundhog Gale, a massive nor’easter that hit on February 2nd, Groundhog Day.

As an eight year old it was thrilling.

Molasses baked beans

It all started out as a normal school day.

Off we walked to our neighbourhood elementary school in a heavy breeze and pelted with rain. Before recess we could see garbage cans being blown down the street and before lunchtime we were told that school was closing due to the storm and we were all to go home.

Most of us were walkers so out into the gale we went to make our way home.

It was the most thrilling walk of my life. With the wind at our backs we were tossed along the rain coated ice like it was some kind of high-speed carnival ride. We were blown into puddles and hung onto trees to catch our breath. We screamed in delight and took the long way home to prolong the fun.

Can you imagine?

Molasses baked beans

Apparently the winds were clocked at over 140 km per hour and there were reports that salt spray from the Bay of Fundy was found on homes more than 10 kilometres inland. I’m sure we were home before it got that bad but still…

My poor mom hadn’t even been notified that school was closed.

Molasses baked beans

Baked beans are the sort of satisfying meal that helps you weather February storms. The long baking time keeps the kitchen cozy (although they can be baked in a crockpot) and leftovers can be eaten with breakfast.

This is the recipe that I grew up with, adapted from The Laura Secord Canadian Cook Book. It has a bit of a bite from the pepper (that’s the sass) to balance the sweetness and develops an amazing depth of flavour. Enjoy these baked beans with oatmeal brown bread , Sarah’s Brown Bread or cracked wheat brown bread

Molasses Baked Beans

  • 2 cups dried navy or pea beans
  • 1 small onion, peeled
  • 1/3 cup brown sugar
  • ½ cup Crosby’s Fancy Molasses
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • 1 ½ tsp. dried mustard
  • ½ tsp. freshly ground black pepper
  • 1 slice of bacon, chopped or 1 Tbsp. butter or olive oil
  • Boiling water
  1. Soak 2 cups of dried navy or white beans in water overnight.
  2. The next day, drain the beans, put them in a pot and cover with water. Bring to a boil, and simmer for 30 minutes (or until the skins break when you blow on them).
  3. Preheat oven to 300 F.
  4. Drain the beans and put them in a large ovenproof pot or bean crock. Bury peeled onion in the middle of the beans.
  5. Mix together and pour over the beans: brown sugar, molasses, salt, dry mustard and pepper. Dab with the butter or oil or sprinkle over the bacon pieces.
  6. Pour over enough boiling water to just cover the beans.
  7. Cover the pot and cook for 4-6 hours, stirring occasionally and adding water if necessary so the beans do not dry out. Take the lid off for the last half hour of cooking.

Tasty tips: You can also add half a peeled apple to the mixture along with the onion. Try adding left over molasses baked beans to your next batch of chili.

One more thing…

If you’re in search of family-friendly food that’s easy to prepare, healthy and tastes good, then sign up to receive blog posts by email..

We’d love to send you our monthly newsletter too. Our Molasses and More newsletter includes cooking tips, menu ideas and featured recipes. Here’s the link to our monthly email sign-up form.

Here’s to eating well, every day,

Bridget signature

52 thoughts on “Molasses baked beans with a touch of sass

  1. Danielle says:

    Hallo…

    I have a question for you,
    the last time a make some bean, very good,
    and 3 days..
    whas rot, in my refrigerator,…

    I follow the recip,and ont no y not good at all..

    thank you…

    1. Bridget Oland says:

      Hi Danielle,
      Baked beans should last more than three days in the fridge, so I’m not sure what went wrong with your recipe. If there is meat in the recipe they won’t last as long.

    2. Monique says:

      Maybe it was just the butter that hardened in the beans or the fat from the bacon, not rote.

  2. Maggie says:

    My aunt used to use yellow or brown eyed beans for this, made for a nice change. I myself add a few drops or hot sauce to my bowl! And, they taste pretty good cold plopped on top of a green salad for lunch the next day!

    1. Bridget Oland says:

      Hi Maggie, THanks for the suggestion to add a bit of hot sauce. Sounds like a delicious addition. I love them cold too!

  3. monica bourque says:

    I have been making baked beans with molasses for many years, and my mother before me, this recipe is almost like mine except I use olive oil instead of bacon or fat pork, my husband loves them.

    1. Bridget Oland says:

      Hi Monica, Like you I never use meat in my recipe, although the original recipe calls for 1/4 lb of fat salt pork! I might try olive oil next time.

      1. Sheila Whitten says:

        How much olive oil?

        1. Hi Sheila, You could substitute olive oil for the tablespoon of butter, although the butter adds a bit of flavour.

  4. Sheila says:

    I triple my recipe and then I can freeze in batches also this is the time for homemade bread/biscuts. Ham and coleslaw.

    1. Bridget Oland says:

      Great suggest. I’m going to do that next time since we love leftovers but never seem to have any.

    2. Judy says:

      I put my beans in mason jars and bath them down for 5 minutes, will last for months and don’t dry out like in the freezer? Just like opening a can of juicey beans.

  5. Baked brown beans are a strong favourite childhood memory for me, too… and I have a similar memory of walking through a storm, but I was in junior high – but could relate to that feeling and it brought me right back to my old family home table – warm and cozy, with the storm raging outside. Home was always such a safe place. I love that feeling. So, these baked beans look heavenly… yet my mom always made pork and beans… always… there wasn’t much pork to eat in the bowl, but the flavour of smoky bacon was strong and prevalent, so I know that more than one piece of bacon was used in her recipe. Reading all the comments here, it is time to make my own. Never have.
    🙂
    Valerie

  6. Lorraine says:

    Hi there;
    I have the beans waiting for me when I get home tonight; made them in the slow cooker on low and added just a bit more water to accommodate this method of cooking. Can’t wait! The recipe has more sugar than my usual one so will let you know how it goes. I am sure the family will love it. Beans and fish cakes; yumm, should chase away the winter blues.

    1. Hi Lorraine, Lucky you to have baked beans waiting at home. I’m wishing I had the same but I do have navy beans soaking on the counter so that’ll be my supper tomorrow night. Fish cakes alongside sounds delicious, must give it a try.

  7. Nancy says:

    I plan on making these this weekend! I’ve been craving homemade beans and the weather is just right here in New Brunswick! 🙂

  8. Rod McFarlane says:

    Bridget I remember that particular storm very well! I lived in the Annapolis valley at the time and because of the freezing rain our home was without power for 7 days! I soaked Jacob Cattle beans last night. Going to try your recipe today and as previously suggested with fish cakes, an original Saturday evening family meal. Watching Wild World of Sports…

  9. Hi Bridget I make a baked bean recipe it has half a cup of tomatoe sauce added extra to your recipe also a ham shank and I add some small pork spare ribs. cook overnight on the slowest heat with a folded towel over the whole container (tradition) and the next morning I can not wait to eat. I am so glad I found your lovely website Crosby’s

    1. Hi Marilyn, Your adaptations sound delicious! Thanks for sharing. Reminds me that I really must get myself a slow cooker.

  10. Danny Rasch says:

    Bridget that reciept is almost like ours except we use yellow eyed beans and fat salt pork and no pepper this has been our reciept passed down for generations, as far as them not lasting long because of the added meat they are usally gone the next day anyway. I live in Edmonton now and baking some beans right now for supper I think I will try the pepper that you suggest in your reciept. I do remember that storm walking home that day from school was fun I lived in Saint John at the time and like your mom my Mother was also not aware of the school closing early

    1. Hi Danny, This has definitely been a baked beans winter on the East Coast. Funny that you recall the Groundhog Gale too. (I think this winter has been as memorable as the winter of ’76.)

  11. Barney says:

    Last year I went looking for a recipe and found yours.I recognize the molasses brand and after reading your story I figured I would try it.I loved the baked beans we used to eat growing up and I missed having them so I decided to give it a try. They turned out great and I make them at least twice a month.I usually make a large batch and they last a few days. My only change is I use more bacon and it is great.
    Thanks.

    1. I Barney, I’m so pleased you’re enjoying the baked beans recipe. The old recipes always seem to be the best.

    2. Sue clark says:

      Can I do these in a slow cooker?

      1. Hi Sue, I haven’t made this recipe in a slow cooker, but you could try on low, keeping a close eye on the liquid so the beans don’t dry out.

  12. Deb says:

    I also remember that Gale. Am I dating myself?;-) These beans remind of the ones my Nan made. Haven’t had them in years. They sound delicious.

  13. Sheilagh says:

    I use pinto beans and reduce the sugar. Also instead of water I whiz a jar of home canned tomatoes. Hubby loves them!

    1. Hi Sheilagh, Love the idea of adding the home canned tomatoes. It must add great texture and flavour. Thanks for the suggestion.

  14. Carol Longue MacDonald says:

    Can you do the beans in the slow cooker with this recipe?

    1. Hi Carol, Yes, this recipe can be adapted to the slow cooker. I have been told they should be cooked on low.

    2. Norman Albert says:

      I use the slow cooker and the beans turn out great. The don’t seem to last very long
      I also remember the Groundhog day Storm the lasted a lot longer then a day. We were city center in out new home and without power for about 10 days. Coleman heaters in the basement well ventilated but kept us from freezing.

      1. Lynn Purdy says:

        I’m glad to hear that the beans do well in the slow cooker. I’m happy that you managed to stay warm.

  15. Laurie Zruna says:

    This is such a great baked beans recipe. I have been making them for many years with yellow eyed beans in my slow cooker. I always have a couple of ham steaks in my freezer that I can dice up in the beans to add great flavour! Recently I have been adding about 1/4 cup Beer and Chipotle BBQ sauce with the other ingredients…..yum! At the beginning of 2015 our youngest son was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes so I am always looking for ways to cut sugar from recipes….but there is no replacement that I am aware of for Crosby’s molasses! It always invokes such comforting memories of growing up in PEI,NS and NB! I have beans soaking now as I write this. And we love ours with what my Mum called Johnny Cake …..hot with butter and what else? Crosby’s Molasses!

    1. Dear Laurie, Such great stories. Thanks for sharing. I love your suggestion to add BBQ sauce to the beans for a change. I too grew up eating Johnny cake — it was always a favourite.

  16. Ester Baker-Duggan says:

    This is a great recipe which I use with variations. I omit meat and add a few drops of liquid smoke instead, also sometimes I substitute the brown sugar and use maple syrup instead. A couple of Tbs. BBQ sauce is a good add as well. Baked beans were a once a week staple during my childhood years and always with homemade bread!

    1. Hi Ester, Thanks for all of the suggestions. Your variations sounds delicious.

  17. Nancy Teed says:

    Just put a pot of these babies in the oven! This is my go-to bean recipe. We absolutely love them! I do make a couple of slight changes which are I chop the onion and mix it in and also I chop a couple of peeled apples and mix in as well. The basically melt into the sauce and I really like it. I also add more pepper – just our preference and a bay leaf while cooking. Although when I first starting making this recipe, I followed the recipe exactly and then starting adjusting a bit. I usually take half the cooked beans and then make my chili out of it. AWESOME! 😀 Thanks for all your great posts and recipes! 😀

    1. Thanks Nancy. I love the suggestion to add apples. I must give that a try.

  18. margie scott says:

    Trying this for my first time!! Hope all goes well !! Look like my Mom made !!

  19. Gary South says:

    I love this recipe but I make these beans all in the same day. I’ve found if you boil the beans for 20-25 minutes as you suggest and let them stand in the boiled water for another 10 minutes they bake up quite nicely in about 4 hours using a dutch oven.
    Like Nancy I add an apple but this is in place of the brown sugar. I also use 2 slices of turkey bacon otherwise I follow your recipe. They’re with fish cakes or toutons and molasses.

    1. Thanks for the suggestions, Gary!

  20. Donna says:

    I,d love to make the oatmeal bread to go with the beans do you have the recipe!

    1. Hi, Donna! Here is the recipe for the oatmeal bread: http://www.crosbys.com/oatmeal-bread/

  21. Jennifer Moore says:

    I enjoyed reading your memories of the Ground Hog Gail! I was in grade 1 and living on the West Side when the storm hit Saint John. My Dad made baked beans with Crosby’s molasses and I am excited to try your recipe!

  22. Doug Turner says:

    Ms. Oland

    An excellent recipe. Reminds me of my mother’s baked beans she used to make for New Year’s Eve.. One small modification gives a bit of piquancy. I add to the mixture over the beans about 1/2 cup of our home made chili sauce -commercial will do. . My mother used catsup, which works well.also.

    Doug Turner in Victoria B.C.

    1. Bridget Oland says:

      Hi Doug, That’s a great suggestion. Thanks.

  23. Carol Arnold says:

    This recipe sounds Yum! Haven’t made baked beans that often but think this recipe will help me try them more often. I lived throug the “Groundhog Day Storm” too. We were very fortunate to have wood furnace and a Kemac(SP?) kitchen stove. Neighbours came for heat, hot coffee, and things cooked on kitchen stove. A good memory also, NO SCHOOL 😉
    This winter reminds me of that winter, only difference is Generator, and not alot of neighbors needing help. No baked beans in freezer, but will have for the rest of winter.
    Thank you for memories and yummy, easy looking recipe!

  24. Cornelius Kenny says:

    Hi Bridget, (love the name, same as my great-grandmother)
    How exactly would you sub the salt fat pork. That’s what my mother used but I wasn’t particularly interested in watching her cook baked beans when I was growing up. Too bad.

    1. Hi Cornelius, Sorry I’m so late replying to your message. If you want to use salt pork you can just bury it in the beans before baking, along with the onion.

  25. Nancy Wisteard says:

    Love baked beans and grew up with them as a staple for Saturday night supper with brown bread. I use diced pancetta and no-fat low-sodium chicken stock in lieu of water.

    1. Hi Nancy, Great suggestions. Those additions must add wonderful flavour.

  26. Judy says:

    I put my beans in mason jars and bath them down for 5 minutes, will last for months and don’t dry out like in the freezer? Just like opening a can of juicey beans.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

104009 Views